There is nothing better than seeing one of your favorite songs played live, but what about having one of your favorite albums played live. Even better right? There is a new emerging trend in the hard rock / metal community; bands playing from start to finish one of their "classic"
(see prior post for definition) albums. Motley Crue has done
Dr. Feelgood from start to finish, Megadeth plans on doing
Rust in Peace this summer, and Metallica did
Master of Puppets a few years ago. What is the driving force behind these decisions? Is it to increase old album sales? Keep their core fan base loyal? Prove that they still can rock like they once did? The answer to the question is unclear on all levels; however it poses anther question; do you really want to hear the whole album?
When bands first start touring they typically have a limited material to work with, and thus a "cookie cutter" show is created. 10 songs on their first alum, only one album out, pretty much guarantees that you will hear those 10 songs. But seasoned bands, as the aforementioned ones, have a catalog that vasts over 20+ years and multiple albums, so why choose just to play the same set over and over again? Seems to me that it would get boring for the band, and really downplay that their music has evolved, and become more complex over the past 20 years.
As a fan I see this as a coin toss. On one side of the coin we get to hear an album in it's entirety; one that most likely we grew up with. We hear songs that probably we would have never heard live, simply because at the time the album dropped, certain songs were not popular enough to be played. On the other side we don't get to hear our new favorite songs. We have to hear songs on an album that we possibly did not love from start to finish.
I have not witnessed a show like this yet, and frankly I guess I would be at a cross road about how I felt about it if it occurred. There are pro's and con's to doing it. Dr. Feelgood is a great album, however it does not include some of my favorite Motley songs like
Home Sweet Home, and
Live Wire, and I just dont know how I would feel if I went to a Motley show and did not hear those two gems.